You read what our guest reviewer thought of Memphis, the newest musical to open on Broadway, but what do the critics think?
Unlike Bye Bye Birdie, which was universally panned, reviews for Memphis were mixed. Here’s what the big media outlets had to say:
NEW YORK TIMES
Sex and race and rock ’n’ roll made for a potent, at times inflammatory, combination in the 1950s, when the new musical “Memphis” is set. But there’s no need to fear that a conflagration will soon consume the Shubert Theater, where the show opened on Monday night. This slick but formulaic entertainment, written by David Bryan and Joe DiPietro, barely generates enough heat to warp a vinyl record, despite the vigorous efforts of a talented, hard-charging cast. While the all-important music, by Mr. Bryan of Bon Jovi, competently simulates a wide range of period rock, gospel and rhythm and blues, the crucial ingredient — authentic soul — is missing in action. Read the full review.
The sensuous, soulful sound of rhythm ‘n’ blues hits the audience right from the start of “Memphis,” the exhilarating new musical now shaking Broadway’s Shubert Theatre. Take a deep breath as the curtain rises because the exuberance doesn’t stop. Read the full review.
You might expect a show called Memphis, with a score by rock keyboardist David Bryan and a book by Joe DiPietro, whose last Broadway outing was the jukebox musical “All Shook Up,” to be an homage to Elvis Presley. It isn’t — and for that, the Presley estate owes Bryan and DiPietro a debt of gratitude. Read the full review.
A talented cast, stirring vocals, athletic dance numbers and vigorous direction supply crowd-pleasing elements in the lively new musical, “Memphis,” as evidenced by the waves of appreciation coming off the audience. But there’s also a nagging predictability to this story of a white DJ who brings rockin’ rhythm and blues from black Beale Street to the mainstream in 1950s Tennessee. The show is entertaining but synthetic, its telepic plotting restitching familiar threads from “Hairspray” and “Dreamgirls,” while covering fictitious ground adjacent to that of recent biopic “Cadillac Records. Read the full review.
AM NEW YORK
Contrary to popular belief, rock and roll did not start with Elvis Presley. The new Broadway musical “Memphis” depicts its birth among black singers in underground nightclubs on the now fabled Beale Street – and how the art form was soon pirated by white businessmen as a form of mass entertainment. Read the full review.
One thought on “The Memphis reviews are in …”